← All posts

2026-11-20 · 8 min read · Western New York

New Appraisal Rules and Unpermitted Work: What Western New York Sellers Should Know

Title card for the article: New Appraisal Rules and Unpermitted Work: What Western New York Sellers Should Know

By Merritt Kreutzer, REALTOR® | WNY Metro Roberts Realty

New appraisal rules and unpermitted work are worth thinking about together if you are planning to sell. The appraisal report that most mortgage lenders rely on has changed. If your home has work that was done without a permit, or a permit that was never closed out, the new report is a good reason to sort out that history before you list, not after a buyer's lender orders the appraisal.

Here is what has actually changed, what has not, and what nobody knows yet.

What is changing with appraisals?

Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, the two companies that buy most conventional mortgages, have redesigned the appraisal report. The new version replaces the familiar forms appraisers have filled out for years with one report built around the details of each property. Instead of long written comments, much more of the information is captured in specific fields, such as how much finished space is above ground and how much is below.

The new report became mandatory for new appraisals delivered to Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac starting November 2, 2026. Lenders that asked for more time were given a temporary exception that lets them keep using the old format for a limited period into 2027. So depending on which lender your buyer uses, the appraisal on your sale could be on either version for a while.

The redesign was also built to work for FHA, VA and USDA loans, but each of those agencies sets its own timing. A buyer's lender can tell you which format applies to their loan.

Do the new appraisal rules require permits?

Not that I can find in the published guidelines. I want to be careful here, because I have heard the change described that way.

Fannie Mae's guide already addresses work done without a permit. If an appraiser identifies an addition that does not have the required permit, the appraiser must comment on the quality and appearance of the work and its effect, if any, on the market value. That rule is about describing the work and what it does to value. It does not say the loan cannot be made, and I have not found anything in the new report's published guidance that requires proof of permits or proof that a licensed contractor did the work.

What I cannot tell you is how every lender will handle it. A lender can set its own requirements on top of Fannie Mae's and Freddie Mac's, and the new report puts more of a home's details in plain view. How lenders respond to that over the coming months is something none of us knows yet.

Why would unpermitted work come up in an appraisal at all?

Because the appraiser is measuring and describing your home, and some of what they see may not match the records.

A finished basement, an addition or a converted porch is easy to spot. Under the new report, finished space is recorded in its own fields, above grade and below grade, and space that does not meet the measuring standard is reported separately with the reason. If the appraiser notes an addition without a permit, the report says so and comments on its effect on value.

Once something like that is in the appraisal, the buyer's lender reads it. The lender may ask questions, and those questions arrive with a closing date already on the calendar.

Is the appraisal the same as the home inspection?

No, and the difference matters for this topic.

The buyer's home inspector works for the buyer and looks at the condition of the house: the roof, the furnace, the wiring, the foundation. The appraiser is hired through the buyer's lender to give an opinion of value, and that report is what the lender relies on to decide how much it will lend. Neither one is a search of the town's permit records.

So a question about past work can come from either direction. The inspector may point out a finished space or an addition that looks newer than the rest of the house. The appraiser may describe it in the report the lender reads. Either way, the question tends to show up after you have accepted an offer, which is the timing you want to avoid.

What could that mean for a seller?

It depends on the lender, the loan and the work. I would not guess at an outcome for your house without the details, and neither should anyone else.

What I can say is how the timing works. Questions that come up after you accept an offer are answered under pressure: the buyer has a mortgage commitment date, you may be buying your next home, and every day matters. If the buyer's lender wants something resolved, the choices are usually some combination of providing documents, getting the work inspected or corrected, renegotiating, or the buyer deciding not to go forward. Your real estate attorney is the one to advise you on your rights and obligations if that happens. The buyer's lender is the one who decides what its loan requires.

Questions you find before you list are different. You decide the order, you get advice, and you choose what to handle and when. My article on how long it takes to sell a house in Lancaster walks through the stages, so you can see where a permit question would fit.

What if I am selling and buying at the same time?

Then the timing matters even more, because a delay on your sale can push on your purchase.

If your next home depends on closing this one, a question from the buyer's lender about past work is not only about this house. It can affect your mortgage commitment, your moving date and the closing on the other side. That is one more reason to know your home's history before you set a listing date and before you make an offer on your next place. My article on selling and buying a home in Lancaster at the same time explains how I think about the order of those two moves.

What should I do before I list?

Start with your own records, then talk it through before anything is set in motion.

  1. Make a list of projects. Finished basements, additions, decks, porches turned into rooms, bathrooms that moved, garages and outbuildings. Include work done by a previous owner if you know about it.
  2. Gather what you have. Permits, final inspection papers, certificates of occupancy, contractor invoices.
  3. Talk with your agent and your real estate attorney. Your attorney can advise you on disclosure and on what checking the town's records could lead to. I can help you see how each option affects your timing.

My article on old building permits before selling in Lancaster goes through this order of steps in more detail, including why I suggest getting advice before you call the building department.

If you are planning projects before you sell, find out whether they need a permit and leave time to close it out, so you are not adding a new open item to the list. My article on what adds the most value before selling in Lancaster can help you decide which projects are worth doing at all.

What should I not assume?

"The new rules mean my sale will fall apart." Nothing I have found in the published guidelines says that. Work without a permit has been part of appraisals for years.

"The appraiser will not notice." The appraiser is there to measure and describe the house. Finished space and additions are part of that job.

"My buyer's lender will treat it the same as the last sale I heard about." Lenders, loan types and the work itself all differ. Ask early.

"This only matters for big additions." A finished lower level is finished space too, and the new report records it on its own.

Where should I start?

If you are thinking about a move in Western New York and want to know whether your home's history could affect the timing, start before you set a listing date. Start with a free conversation about your next chapter, and we can put the paperwork, the timing and the order of steps together. My Lancaster checklist for getting ready to sell covers the rest of your preparation, and my article on how closing works in Western New York explains where the appraisal fits once you have a buyer.

What questions come up about the new appraisal rules and unpermitted work?

Do the new appraisal rules require permits for past work?

Not in anything I have found from Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac. The appraiser must comment on an addition without a required permit and its effect on value. A lender can set its own requirements, so ask the buyer's lender what their loan requires.

When did the new appraisal report start?

It became mandatory for new appraisals delivered to Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac on November 2, 2026. Lenders granted a temporary exception can keep using the old format for a limited time into 2027.

Does this apply to FHA and VA loans?

The new report was designed to work for FHA, VA and USDA loans, but each agency sets its own timing. The buyer's lender can tell you which format their appraisal uses.

What should I do if my house has work done without a permit?

Gather what papers you have, then talk with your real estate attorney and your agent before you list, so you can decide the order of steps with good advice instead of under a closing deadline.

Free checklist

Before You List: The Seller's Prep Checklist

What to fix, what to clear and what to clean first, in the order that saves you time, before your home goes on the market.

  • A timeline that starts 6 to 12 months out, repairs first
  • Declutter, depersonalize, deep clean: room by room, in that order
  • The records buyers and their attorneys will ask for

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

The method

Where this fits in how I sell