2026-11-21 · 12 min read · Western New York
My Lancaster, NY House Backs Up to Open Land. What Do I Tell Buyers When I Sell?
By Merritt Kreutzer, REALTOR® | WNY Metro Roberts Realty
If your Lancaster, NY house backs up to open land, what do you tell buyers when you sell? Tell them what is there today, share what you know and can show on paper, and leave out any promise about what happens to that land later. I have lived in Lancaster for 18 years and I serve on the Town of Lancaster Zoning Board of Appeals, and the order I would work in is simple: find out how the land is zoned and whether your own property is in an agricultural district before you list, then let those answers shape your paperwork and your listing. The views in this article are my own, not the board's.
A field, a tree line or a stretch of land with no houses on it is often one of the first things a buyer notices from the back window. It is also one of the first things they ask about. "Can someone build there?" is a fair question, and it deserves a better answer than a guess.
You do not need to have every answer. You do need to know which answers exist, where they come from, and which ones are not yours to give.
Why does open land come up so often when you sell in Lancaster?
Lancaster has been turning farmland into neighborhoods for a long time, and you can still see that change from a lot of back yards.
Many of the subdivisions off Aurora and in both directions off Central on the north end of town were farmland before they were neighborhoods. Along the older roads, farmhouses still sit one at a time where the land used to be worked. Depending on where you live in town, the view out back might be a neighbor's yard, a tree line, a park or a field.
Farming is part of the picture too. Erie County's agricultural district maps have included land in the Town of Lancaster, and parcels can be added during yearly enrollment periods. So the land behind one house may be part of a working farm, the land behind another may be zoned for homes, and the land behind a third may be a town park. From the back deck, they can look the same.
That is why the answer for your house starts with the land itself, not with what is true somewhere else in town.
Can the field behind my Lancaster house be built on?
You usually cannot tell by looking, and neither can a buyer. Several things decide it, and each one has a place you can check.
Zoning. The Town of Lancaster's zoning law divides the town into districts, including Agricultural Residential, Single-Family Residential, Multifamily Residential and several commercial and industrial districts. The district boundaries are shown on the town's Official Zoning Map, which is on file with the Town Clerk. If your home is in the Village of Lancaster, the village has its own zoning code with its own map. A district's name tells you its category. The rules for what can be built in it are in the code itself.
Who owns it and what has already been approved. Open land can belong to a farmer, a private owner, a builder or the town. A field might also be part of a subdivision that was approved years ago and simply has not been built yet. The property records and the town's records are where that shows up.
Whether the zoning changes. Zoning is not permanent. In a New York town, the town board decides zoning amendments after public notice and a public hearing. A new subdivision typically goes through planning board review, with public hearings advertised in a local newspaper. In Lancaster, Town Board agendas and minutes are posted on the town's website.
So the useful answer to "can it be built on?" usually sounds like this: here is how it is zoned today, here is who owns it, and here is whether anything is pending. That is far more helpful to a buyer than "no" or "probably not," and it is an answer you can give with confidence.
What you should not do is answer for the landowner or the town. You do not control either one.
What should I find out before I list?
You can do this part at your kitchen table, before anyone else is involved.
Find your property line. Your survey, usually in the papers from when you bought, shows where your lot ends. Plenty of homeowners have mowed, planted or stored things a few feet past their line for years without thinking about it. Know where the line is before a buyer's attorney asks.
Look up the zoning district. Find your own property and the land behind it on the town's zoning map, or ask the Town Clerk's office. If you are in the Village of Lancaster, check with the village.
Check for an agricultural district. Erie County's online mapping system lets you look up agricultural districts by parcel. Check your own property first, because that answer affects your paperwork. Then check the neighboring land, because it helps you answer buyers.
Look at what is pending. Search the Town Board and Planning Board agendas for the road names and addresses around you. If a rezoning or a subdivision has been discussed near your home, you want to know before you list, not after a buyer finds it.
Gather anything you have on paper. An easement, a right of way, an agreement that lets a neighbor or a farmer use part of your lot, a notice about a nearby project. Put it in the same folder as your survey and your abstract of title.
My article on what to do before selling a house in Lancaster covers the rest of the preparation.
What do I have to tell buyers about the land?
In New York, the seller of a house generally completes a Property Condition Disclosure Statement and delivers it to the buyer before the buyer signs a binding contract. Two questions on that form relate to land.
One asks whether the property is located in an agricultural district. The other asks whether anyone other than you has a lease, an easement or any other right to use or occupy part of the property.
If your property is in an agricultural district, New York law also requires a separate disclosure notice when a purchase contract is presented. The notice tells the buyer that farming happens in the district and may bring noise, dust and odors, and both the seller and the buyer sign it before the sale.
The open land behind you is a different matter. If it is not part of your property, its zoning is public information, and anyone can look it up. What you know about it is still worth talking through with your real estate attorney, especially if a project has been proposed nearby. Your attorney advises you on disclosure and the contract. I do not give legal advice. What I can do is help you decide how that information fits into your listing and your timing.
How should my listing describe the view?
Describe what is there now. Do not describe what you hope stays there.
"Backs up to open land" is a description. "No rear neighbors, ever" is a promise you cannot keep. "Wooded view" is fine when it is true today. "Will always be private" is not yours to say.
Photos follow the same rule. Show the back yard as it is, and if a photo was taken in another season, say so. A field in July and a field in February look very different, and a buyer touring in winter should not be surprised by either one.
This matters more than it might seem. A buyer who loves the view will ask about it, and the buyer's attorney may ask too. If your listing promised something, every answer after that has to explain it away. If your listing described it accurately, the answers simply fill in the detail.
Does open land behind my house change my price?
I would not guess at that in general, and I would be careful with anyone who does.
Some buyers will see a field and think of room and quiet. Others will think about the unknowns, or about the noise, dust and odors the state's own notice mentions when a farm is nearby. The same setting can be a reason to choose a home or a reason to keep looking, depending on the buyer.
I price a home against the homes a buyer would line up next to it: the same part of town, a similar age and size, and a similar setting where those sales exist. A home backing up to a field and a home backing up to a neighbor's fence are not automatically the same comparison, even on the same street.
My article on how to price your home in Lancaster explains how I build that range.
What if something has been proposed on that land?
Then the order you handle it in matters.
First, read the public record so you know what has actually been proposed and where it stands. A rezoning request, a sketch plan and a final approval are very different stages, and a proposal can change or stall along the way.
Second, talk with your attorney about how it should be handled in your disclosure and your contract.
Third, make your timing decision based on your own plans, not on predicting what the town will do. If you need to move this spring, a proposal that may take a long time to resolve is not a reason to put your life on hold. If you were undecided anyway, it is one more piece of information, not the whole decision.
What causes trouble is the reverse order: listing first, hoping nobody notices, and then answering questions about the project in the middle of a negotiation.
What if the home I am buying next in Lancaster backs up to open land?
Then switch sides and ask the same questions.
Before you make an offer, look up the zoning of the land behind the house, check the agricultural district map, and search the town's agendas for the road. During attorney review, ask your attorney whether anything else should be checked before you close. If there is a working farm nearby, visit at different times of day.
If you are moving from one part of Lancaster to another, my article on moving up to more space without leaving Lancaster covers the other things that change from one part of town to the next.
What assumptions cause trouble?
"It has been a field for 30 years, so it will stay a field." How long land has been open tells you nothing about its zoning or its owner's plans.
"Agricultural Residential means no houses." The name of a zoning district describes a category. What can be built in it is in the town's zoning code.
"The neighbor told me it can never be built on." A neighbor's memory is not a record. Check the map, the ownership and the agendas.
"I do not need to mention the farm." If your own property is in an agricultural district, there is a question on the disclosure form and a separate notice. Ask your attorney.
"My back yard ends at the tree line." Your survey decides where your yard ends.
How could this look in practice?
Here are two hypothetical situations. They are illustrations, not client stories.
One homeowner lives on one of Lancaster's older roads, with a field behind the house that a farmer has worked for years. Before listing, they check the county map and learn that their own parcel is in an agricultural district. Their attorney prepares the disclosure notice along with the rest of the paperwork, and the listing describes the setting as it is. When buyers ask about the field, the answer is ready: here is the zoning, here is who owns it, and nothing is pending.
Another homeowner lives in a newer subdivision with open land beyond the back lot line. While looking through Planning Board agendas, they find a sketch plan for a subdivision on nearby land. Instead of listing right away and hoping it does not come up, they read the record, talk with their attorney about how to handle it, and keep their spring move on schedule. When a buyer asks, they share what they found.
Neither homeowner could promise what would happen to the land. Both knew what was true today and where the answers came from.
If you are not sure how the town and the villages fit together, my Lancaster area page is a good place to start. And if your preparation turns up older projects on your own lot, my article on old building permits before selling in Lancaster covers who to talk to first.
What is the next step if I am thinking about selling?
Start with the land you can see from your back window and the papers you already have. The free guide at the end of this article, Before You List, the Seller's Prep Checklist, walks you through what to gather and what to settle before your home goes on the market. If you would rather talk it through first, a free conversation with me is always an option, and you do not need a listing date to have one.
What questions come up about selling a Lancaster house next to open land?
Do I have to tell buyers my Lancaster property is in an agricultural district?
New York's Property Condition Disclosure Statement asks whether the property is located in an agricultural district. State law also requires a separate notice to the buyer when a purchase contract is presented for property in one, signed by both of you. Your attorney prepares that paperwork with you.
How do I find out how the land behind my Lancaster house is zoned?
In the Town of Lancaster, district boundaries are shown on the Official Zoning Map, which is on file with the Town Clerk. The Village of Lancaster has its own zoning code and map. The rules for each district are in the zoning code.
Can I tell buyers the field behind my house will never be built on?
Not unless you have a document that says so. Describe the land as it is today, share the zoning and ownership you found, and let the records speak for what comes next.
Should I wait to sell if a subdivision has been proposed near my house?
Not by itself. Find out what stage the proposal is in, talk with your attorney about disclosure, and time your sale around your own plans rather than a prediction about the town's decision.
